Celebrating
its 40th anniversary today is the fourth "official" Public Image Ltd.
studio LP, This Is What You Want... This Is What You Get, which was
released on July 6th, 1984. I use the qualifier "official" due to the
fact that the unfinished and aborted Commercial Zone album was
surreptitiously released by jilted former founding member, Keith Levene,
in January of that year on his own independent label imprint. His
version of the album contained the original recordings that had been
created throughout 1982 & 1983 at Park South studio, NYC, up until
his unceremonious dismissal from the band by John Lydon following a
dispute over an alternate mix of the single, This Is Not A Love Song.
Following his departure, Levene spirited away master tapes from the
session to release on his own mix, leaving remaining members, John Lydon
and Martin Atkins, holding an empty bag when it came time to produce an
official version of the album for Virgin Records.
Lydon
and Atkins returned to the UK after their 1983 Japanese mini tour, for
which they'd hired a trio of New York lounge musicians to fill out the
band's empty slots vacated by Levene and bassist Pete Jones, who
departed of his own accord immediately after Keith's sacking. Once in
the UK, they set up at Maison Rouge Studios and began to rebuild the
album from the ground up. Five of the Commercial Zone songs got a
reboot, including "Bad Life" (originally titled "Mad Max"), "This Is Not
a Love Song" (originally titled "Love Song"), "Solitaire" (entitled
"Young Brits" on the second pressing of Commercial Zone), "The Order of
Death" (originally titled "The Slab"), and "Where Are You?" (originally
titled "Lou Reed Part 2"). Two new songs were recorded from scratch:
"The Pardon" and "Tie Me To the Length Of That", with the latter being
improvised in the studio with Lydon and Atkins playing all the
instruments. For most of the rest of the album, the NYC lounge
musicians, plus a few others, worked as session players. The track,
"1981", was actually an outtake from the Flowers of Romance sessions,
though some minor overdubs were added to bring it up to snuff for the
current LP.
Though PiL had
scored a hit with the single version of This Is Not A Love Song, using
the Park South recordings with Levene and Pete Jones, the album was
received with a large degree of ambivalence, feeling like the soul of
the band had been supplanted by the use of faceless studio musicians.
Only "Tie Me To the Length of That" really offered any sense of proper
PiL music, principally because it lacked the sterile presence of studio
hired guns. Still, the album's version of "The Order Of Death" has
popped up in numerous soundtracks over the years, including the 1990
science fiction-horror film, Hardware, and on the soundtrack to the 1999
horror film, The Blair Witch Project. It was also featured in the Miami
Vice episode "Little Miss Dangerous", the Mr. Robot episode
"eps2.7_init_5.fve", and the Industry episode "There Are Some Women...".
It also appears in Season 2 Episode 6 of The Umbrella Academy when the
Hargreeves siblings take the elevator to the Tiki Lounge to meet with
their father. Finally, it appears in the 2023 remake of System Shock, as
the music for the end credits.
When
it came out, I was at the tail end of my obsession with the band.
After the stunning artistic breakthroughs of their first three albums,
Commercial Zone felt like a bastard echo of what might have been, while
its troubled twin felt like a synthetic imposter version of the band.
The release of the Live In Tokyo album, which sounded even more shallow
and perfunctory as an imitation of the band, had driven the sense of
demise further into the ground. In a sense, TIWYW...TIWYG feels like a
capstone to the PiL story, at least as far as the project being a real
band. After that, it seemed more like a Lydon solo project, and the
sense of musical innovation felt like it had left the building. Without
the presence of Keith, Wobble or Martin, who left after touring to
support this album, the game had changed and the rules were all
different, so I was pretty much out as far as following the band, at
least to the degree that I'd been enraptured by them during their
heyday.